Don’t Leave It to Chance: Why Formal Associate Agreements Are Essential in Your Practice.
As healthcare clinics grow, the need for added support becomes unavoidable. Whether in dentistry, therapy, chiropractic care, or family medicine, many clinics meet rising patient demand by engaging associates as independent contractors rather than hiring employees or forming partnerships. This model offers flexibility and scalability, but it also carries real risk if the working relationship isn’t properly documented from the outset.
Many clinic owners rely on verbal agreements or outdated templates when bringing on associates. These informal arrangements may work in the short term, but when things go wrong, they offer little clarity and even less protection.
The Real-World Consequences of Informality
Consider the Ontario case of Coscarella Dentistry Professional Corp. v. Harvey, where an independently contracted dental associate left after 15 years to open his own clinic across the street. He contacted all his patients, brought five staff with him, and began competing with the original practice. The clinic owners claimed over $1 million in lost profits as a result of these actions. However, there was no written agreement in place—no non-solicitation clause, no confidentiality provisions, and no clear definition of goodwill ownership. As a result, the court found no wrongdoing. The decision affirmed that patients are not “owned” by the clinic and emphasized that, absent a contract, the associate was entitled to notify and treat his former patients.
This case illustrates what many professional regulators already advise: a formal associate agreement is essential for protecting your practice’s interests.
What Should a Good Associate Agreement Cover?
The best associate agreements don’t just outline start dates and pay splits. They establish the legal, professional, and operational framework of the relationship in a way that is enforceable and fair. At minimum, your agreement should clearly address:
- Nature of the relationship: Confirm that the associate is an independent contractor, not an employee or partner. Make it clear that they have no authority to bind the clinic or claim ownership.
- Compensation and billing: Explain how fees are collected, when payments are made, and how overhead expenses are handled.
- Professional standards: Outline licensure requirements, insurance obligations, hours of service, and alignment with clinic values.
- Confidentiality and data protection: Safeguard patient records, internal communications, and sensitive business information.
- Termination and exit obligations: Specify how either party can end the relationship, what notice is required, and clarify whether severance applies.
- Post-departure conduct: Include fair non-solicitation and non-competition terms to protect patient relationships and clinic goodwill.
- Dispute resolution and liability: Set out a clear process for resolving disagreements and ensure that each party remains accountable for their actions.
These terms not only protect your business, they offer clarity to the associate as well. When expectations are clearly defined, misunderstandings are less likely. If disputes do arise, they are more easily resolved.
A Balanced Approach Benefits Both Sides
The strongest agreements are not one-sided. A fair and clearly written contract supports a respectful and professional working relationship. For clinic owners, it means safeguarding goodwill and financial stability. For associates, it ensures transparency and preserves their autonomy as independent professionals.
Professional organizations, including the CMPA, recommend that agreements cover a broad scope of the working relationship. They also encourage both parties to seek independent legal and financial advice before signing. These steps help ensure that the arrangement truly reflects the intent of both parties.
With increased scrutiny on employment classifications, clarity around independent contractor status is more important than ever. A well-drafted agreement can help prevent confusion, tax issues, or regulatory concerns about how the associate’s role is defined and supervised.
Final Thoughts
Growing your clinic is a milestone, but it brings responsibility too. Every associate you bring on represents both an opportunity and a potential risk. With the right contract in place, you can support your clinic’s growth while protecting what you’ve built.
Our firm works with healthcare providers across Ontario to create associate agreements that reflect current legal standards and the practical realities of clinic life. If you haven’t reviewed your associate contracts recently, now is the time.
Trust alone isn’t enough. A handshake might start a good relationship, but a proper contract helps preserve it.
If you have questions about your existing associate agreements or need help putting one in place, please contact Dave Thompson or Trent Howard.
References:
- Coscarella Dentistry Professional Corp. v. Harvey, 2024 ONSC 337
Ontario Medical Association: https://www.oma.org/
DoctorCare / Well Health Technologies: https://www.doctorcare.ca/blog/
Hamilton specific:
Greater Hamilton Health Network: https://greaterhamiltonhealthnetwork.ca/
Industry specific:
Association of Ontario Midwives: https://www.ontariomidwives.ca/
Ontario Dental Association (ODA): https://www.oda.ca/member-resources/member-communications/ontario-dentist-journal/